Showing posts with label Tort Reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tort Reform. Show all posts

April 10, 2009

Why Universal Health Care Will Not Be Cheaper Than What We Have Now

Dave Schuler, as so often, hits the nail right on the head -- even if we had universal health care, we'd still be paying an astronomical amount of money for health care because health care providers will not accept pay cuts. Which, if true, would also mean that tort reform isn't going to do a thing to reduce the high cost of health care in this country.

In other words, don't blame the greedy lawyers for the high cost of health care - blame the greedy doctors. Now that is a position I can wholeheartedly endorse.

January 23, 2008

We Don't Need Tort Reform

We need judges and juries. People whose critical thinking skills are not under anesthesia. We need to trust these people to sort through the good cases from the bad ones. The system works fine with smart people who can see through bullshit.

Today I was pleasantly reminded that even weak judges can see through bullshit, as my colleague won a case that has dragged on for far too long; after five weeks of trial (it should have taken only one) the plaintiff rested and the judge granted my colleague's nonsuit motion because this was the Seinfeld Trial -- a lot of talk about nothing. If the judge had been stronger, it wouldn't have taken this long to get to this point. But we did get there.

Then I see all these ads floating around the internet saying that "Lawsuit Abuse Is Real," with the picture of those poor people who got sued by that OCD former administrative law judge on a poorly-written law in D.C. for the missing pair of pants. So sure, lawsuit abuse happens. Our client shouldn't have been sued in that case my colleague just won. But it would be worse if people couldn't file lawsuits. The guardians against lawsuit abuse ought not to be legislators -- they are judges and juries.

June 8, 2007

Tort Reform: Good For Thee, But Not For Me

Noted tort reformer Robert Bork has sued the Yale Club of New York for a routine trip-and-fall negligence case. He’s asked for over $1,000,000 in compensatory damages, punitive damages, attorney’s fees and prejudgment interest. California and Tennessee, which I know about, are apparently no different from New York in not permitting those remedies for routine negligence claims like this one. The previous link also contains an interesting analysis indicating that Bork’s attorneys are a little bit too high-powered to be good choices for a soft-tissue personal injury claim like this. (Proof that BIGLAW “attorneys and professionals” don’t necessarily know what they’re doing any better than so-called “street lawyers.”) So perhaps we can understand why the national law firm of Arrogant, Expensive & Condescending, LLP screwed that one up, thinking that those sorts of remedies might be available as they would be in the securities cases they’re used to handling. But their client – more than just a lawyer, he was only a few votes away from being on the U.S. Supreme Court – should have known better himself before authorizing the complaint. And it’s as graphic a demonstration as I can think of that tort reform is a great idea as long as it doesn’t affect the tort reformer’s remedies when he gets hurt himself.

April 25, 2007

Fred Thompson on Federalism

I have initially been moderately discomfited but at the same time fascinated with the phenomenon of Fred Thompson being wooed by social conservatives to seek the Presidency. Note that Thompson has still not even so much as formed an exploratory committee and his current early-season popularity with GOP voters is largely a reflection of dissatisfaction with the socially tolerant politics that the current front-runners are bringing to the table.

It's facile, though, to suggest that this much sustained excitement and interest can have gone unnoticed, and Thompson has been making moves that seem to be clearing the way for his path to seek the nomination. At the same time, it's clear that Thompson's a pretty smart guy, and he must realize that he needs to reach out to more than just social conservatives to actually win the nomination. So, he writes in National Review Online this little bit, nicely calculated to appeal to Republicans like me, who care less about social issues and more about seeing things get done in the right way by people with principles:

Republicans have struggled in recent years, because they have strayed from basic principles. Federalism is one of those principles. It is something we all give lip service to and then proceed to ignore when it serves our purposes. [¶] Adhering to the principles of federalism is not easy. As one who was on the short end of a couple of 99-1 votes, I can personally attest to it. Federalism sometimes restrains you from doing things you want to do. You have to leave the job to someone else — who may even choose not to do it at all. However, if conservatives abandon this valued principle that limits the federal government, or if we selectively use it as a tool with which to reward our friends and strike our enemies, then we will be doing a disservice to our country as well as the cause of conservatism.


It's worth noting that Thompson at least claims to have put his money where his mouth is on this issue, and that he does seem to continue to take heat from some conservatives for voting against the party line because of federalism principles. I've not looked in depth at all of his voting record, but his article was mainly about tort reform. This is (or at least it ought to be) almost purely a state-level debate; the Federal government properly should have little to say about tort law in most situations. Thompson should be commended for being willing to swim against the tide and stand on Constitutional grounds rather than doing what is politically popular (at least within his party).

It's also worth noting that Thompson, as have many conservative luminaries before him, is critical of the way that Republicans have chosen to govern in recent years. So I feel better about the possibility of a Thompson candidacy now for two reasons -- first, he's made a creditable case for himself as being willing to defend and fight for his principles against all comers, and second, his principles seem to have a substantial root in an understanding of the Constitution, which is one of those things that I happen to think is very good and worth defending.

April 12, 2007

Sorry Advice

This article confirms something I have long strongly suspected -- doctors are discouraged from using phrases like "I'm sorry" by their malpractice insurance carriers (and the lawyers they employ). This is intended to avoid having the doctor make an admission of liability in the event of a malpractice suit (and the indignity of looking like an adorable puppy).

Now, we all know that doctors make mistakes like everyone else, and the law of malpractice is there to compensate the patients and their families who get hurt when that happens. (Contrary to a popular misunderstanding in the lay public, doctors are almost never hit with punitive damages in malpractice cases.) And no one suggests that doctors should enjoy a blanket immunity from tort liability if they do make mistakes.

But doctors win most medical malpractice lawsuits that go to trial -- you can look up the statistics on that yourself. You can probably also look up the amounts of money that are paid out in settlements and verdicts, and chances are, you'll find that settlements are higher than verdicts. That's because insurance companies and defense lawyers know when they have a real problem and when they have a case they can win, and they settle out the cases where there is a real issue. These are difficult cases for plaintiffs to win, for a lot of reasons, and there are already a lot of hurdles placed in the way of plaintiffs to pursue those kinds of remedies.

Having spent some time working the plaintiff's end of such lawsuits, I can tell you that a sane plaintiff's attorney is not going to put any significant weight on a doctor's statement of "I'm sorry." Other statements the doctor makes can be very significant, but "I'm sorry" is an inherently ambiguous remark; it can too easily be explained as expressing regret over the outcome of an unsuccessful procedure rather than as an admission of liability. In 99.99% of all cases, the jury will only get a second-hand description of the context and tone of that remark and they will give the benefit of the doubt to the doctor, every time. Doctors are sympathetic defendants as a general rule anyway -- that is, except for the doctors who are arrogant pricks. And refusing to say "I'm sorry" or otherwise express sympathy for the human emotions resulting from an unsuccessful procedure only feeds in to the stereotype of arrogance from which doctors (and other professionals, like attorneys) suffer.

The doctor interviewed by CNN in the linked article is lobbying for a law making statements of sympathy like "I'm sorry" inadmissible to prove negligence. This would open up a gigantic can of worms for a trial court judge, which would be better left to the lawyers and parties to sort out on their own. When is a doctor's remark an innocent expression of sympathy, and when does it evidence knowledge of a mistake? If the doctor knows he made a mistake, that seems like important evidence for the jury to hear and it should be admissible. If the doctor is trying to be nice, holding that effort at human decency against him will probably backfire against the plaintiff.

While it's rarely a surprise when a popular media report about the law misses some important details, the CNN article does an unusually terrible job of distinguishing an actual admission of negligence from a generalized statement of sympathy like "I'm sorry," and I suspect that is because the proposed law is similarly nebulous in its approach to making that distinction. This is as much proof as I need that this change in the law is a bad idea.

What needs to change is the advice that malpractice defense lawyers give their doctor clients.

The doctor in the CNN article linked above found that when he disregarded his lawyer's advice and told his patients "I'm sorry" after an unsuccessful procedure, he enhanced the bond of trust between doctor and patient, and was generally able to work with the patient further to get a good final result -- which is what both doctor and patient wanted all along. Had he used a more neutral, less caring remark like, "That's too bad," he would have angered his patient and increased his chances of being sued for medical malpractice -- before he had a chance to make the situation right.

I've had tens, if not hundreds, of clients say that they didn't want to go after a doctor who was nice to them -- even if it turned out that was the doctor who actually made a significant mistake. The doctor who cares is, by definition, a "good" doctor and not a target for litigation in the minds of most patients. It's the doctor who's an arrogant bastard who should get sued. The patient, my potential client, is not concerned with actual liability because figuring out which doctor is actually liable (if any doctor is at all) is far too difficult for a layperson to do. So they latch on to things they can understand instead, and what they do understand is whether they've been treated like human beings or sides of beef.

So based on that, when I have spoken with doctors, as individuals or in small groups, I've always encouraged them to use these kinds of phrases -- not to trick them into saying something that would realistically come back to haunt them, but to offer good-faith advice about how to avoid being in a situation like that in the first place. Good medical skills are important, making good medical decisions is important, having a large mass of medical knowledge in the doctor's brain and library is important. But the most effective tool a doctor has for avoiding a malpractice suit is her bedside manner, not her skills. Not once has a doctor ever said that this was bad advice, and most have admitted that a great many of their colleagues have terrible demeanors with patients.

So does a doctor face a risk by telling a patient "I'm sorry"? Yes, but the risk is minimal, and the rewards from that risk substantially outweigh the downside. Doctors shouldn't need a change in the law to start expressing sympathy for their patients -- they need to get better advice from their lawyers instead.

March 5, 2007

Just an Example

You would be best advised to not oversimplify the dynamics of the Supreme Court.

Traditionally, one would say Breyer, Souter, Ginsburg, and Stevens are liberals, Roberts, Alito, Souter, and Thomas are conservatives, and Kennedy is usually conservative but often votes liberal. (Or, if you’re really conservative yourself, you think Kennedy usually votes liberal but sometimes votes conservative.) But the breakdown of the Justices and the way they look at things is much more complex and nuanced than “liberal-conservative” and this simplistic way of looking at the law at its highest level is dangerously inaccurate.

This case is an example of that. The question: the scope of a punitive damage award against the big tobacco companies for contributing to a man’s death from lung cancer. The breakdown: Stephen Breyer wrote the majority opinion, joined by Chief Justice Roberts, Anthony Kennedy, David Souter, and Samuel Alito. Dissenting were Ruth Bader Ginsburg, and joined by John Paul Stevens, Antonin Scalia, and Clarence Thomas; the primary dissent was written by Justice Ginsburg and Justices Scalia and Thomas joined her opinion. The entire slip opinion is reasonably short, and I will probably be using it in my future classes because it’s much shorter than the State Farm v. Campbell case I have been for the purpose of describing the modern method of determining punitive damages.

October 5, 2006

Grading Papers

Quite possibly the least enjoyable thing about being a teacher is grading papers. I only put myself through this once per class -- at the first papers my students turn in. But I have to do it because if I don't, the papers get worse and not better. I have one down and five to go right now. It's tedious and the writing is terrible.

The first paper I have my students do is an analysis of two tort reform proposals. I don't care if they are for or against the proposals, but I'm looking for the ability to normatively evaluate an idea. Here's a sample of what I got tonight in my first paper:

In section 135, it is proposed that subsection (a) is rewritten. Before the rewriting, it sounded like the Director had all the power to decide rather a person whom filed an application for a patent would be granted that patent or not. It was in the Director’s opinion rather the patent was already in use or not. With the revision, the Director has to do more research to make sure that a patent does not already exist.

Now, you may be wondering (because George and I sure are) what exactly this has to do with tort reform. The answer is nothing. It's about a proposed change in patent law. You'll also notice a few problems with the writing. Passive voice, misuse of words, guessing at facts, undefined jargon. The reader has no idea who this "Director" is and why it's a bad thing that he gets to decide who gets a patent and who doesn't.

It goes on and on like this. I'll be up until midnight getting this all done, so I'd better stop blogging and get back to it. If you're religious, pray for me

UPDATE: It got worse. Get a load of this:


Some of the Advantages of Tort Reform are a $250,000 cap on the pain and suffering. The tort reform would improve on system. People are trying to sue doctors for any little detail. This is making our medical insurance rates go up and our medicine. Sometimes some of these cases are so minor and people want to sue for millions of dollars that doctor do not even know how they are suppose to treat people for there medical condition. When our society sees through the media how one person can get all this money for such a minor condition, he or she may want to do this too. They feel that this is a get rich scheme. Another advantage would be to give judges the power to overturn unwarranted jury verdicts and rewards. If the judge feels that the case is false based on other cases than the judge can overturn the verdicts. That would make attorney think twice before getting a case that a person will be committing fraud. The bill the reform would ensure doctors have less cases filed against them, which are not serious. This would be a big advantage since the doctors would pass on the savings to the Health care system and the medicine.

In the Reform that deals with no child left behind the advantage of this reform is that the parent and the child will be able to decide on the education. One of the aspects and advantages that it focuses one is literacy, which is very important to each child.


Literacy is very important to each child? How about to college students?

You may well ask, "Um, TL, what does the No Child Left Behind Act have to do with tort reform?" And all I can do in response is cry, like Renaldo:


February 20, 2006

Do We Need More Medical Malpractice Reform?

The Tennessee arm of the AMA says yes. The Nashville Tennessean says no. The data in favor of that argument is pretty compelling.

In 2004, there were a total of six medical malpractice judgments, totaling $1.9 million. In that time, the insurers collected $327 million in premiums, and 444 claims were settled by insurance companies totaling $108 million. According to the report, 81% of malpractice claims in Tennessee resulted in no payment. (This per the Tennessean's recital of data from the Tennessee Department of Commerce and Insurance.) The TMA actually says the failure ratio for claimants is closer to 88%, and claims that there were 1,534 lawsuits with defense costs totalling "more than $16 million." These numbers vary with the official reports from the state government, so I will use the state government's statistics when there is a conflict.

A little math: 444 claims were settled in 2004. 6 resulted in plaintiff's verdicts. That was 19% of all cases resolved in 2004, since the other 81% resulted in no recovery for the plaintiff. 444 plus 6 divided by 19% is 2,818 malpractice cases resolved a year. (Note, the TMA says there were 1,534 lawsuits, and the state's data is that there were 2,818 claims. That suggests that nearly half the claims tendered to insurers never were abandonded based on insufficient merit or insufficient damages. This seems about right to me based on my own experience.)

The Tennessee Department of Health Services states that in 2004 the population of Tennessee was 5,897,306. In July of 2005, there were 18,137 valid licenses to practice medicine in Tennessee outstanding, and 13,562 doctors actually did practice in Tennessee.

So first, we see that there is only one doctor for every 435 Tennesseans. The number seems low at first glance, but consider: if a doctor takes two weeks of vacation a year and doesn't work weekends, she works about 250 days. Her "fair share" of patients is 435, meaning an average of less than two patients a day. Not so bad from the doctor's point of view.

By way of comparison, let's look at California. There were 92,852 California-licensed doctors working in California in 2004, serving a state population of 36,591,000, for a ratio of one doctor for every 394 Californians. Tennessee has fewer doctors, but not by much.

Second, we see that there are .208 claims made against the average doctor per year. I can attest from personal experience that virtually every doctor I worked with, sued, or deposed in just under a year working for The Law Office of the Great Man had not been the subject of a malpractice complaint in fifteen, twenty, or more years of practice. It seems that most of these complaints are going to a smaller segment of the medical profession. However, this is not evidence that I can readily verify with statistics. But, we do know that 81% of all claims result in zero recovery to the claimant. So that means that there is slightly less than a 4% chance that any malpractice claim will produce any money.

On that subject, the third point is that the total amount of money paid out for all this activity seems both quite low and quite high, depending on how you look at it. Verdicts in 2004 were $1.9 million and settlements were $108 million. Rounding up, that gives us $110 million paid out on 4% of the 2,818 claims in 2004 -- an average of $39,000 per claim, or put another way, $975,000 per successful claim. That's claims, not verdicts. There were only six verdicts, and they averaged $316,666.67 each -- less than a third of the average pre-verdict settlement. This math looks pretty scary to a plaintiff's attorney, let me tell you. Then add to that the fact that before filing a medical malpractice lawsuit, the attorney needs to have an expert witness lined up already, so that's effectively a five thousand dollar filing fee which the attorney personally risks -- in pursuit of that one-in-twenty-five case that will actually produce money.

Fourth, subtracting "claims paid" from "premiums collected" gives us total gross revenue for the insurance companies of over $217 million in 2004. From that, of course, we must also take away defense costs. According to TMA, insurers incurred "more than $16 million in defense costs" in 2004. Let's give them the benefit of the doubt and say it's an even $17 million -- that's still a bulk profit of $200,000,000, a fifth of a billion dollars, representing a profit margin of more than 61%. So even after the cost of defending against all these "frivolous lawsuits" is taken into account, sixty-one cents of every dollar paid in premiums by doctors in Tennessee end up in the insurance company's coffers -- not paid out to defense lawyers, not paid out to settle claims, but put in the insurance company's operating and investment accounts.

Insurance companies need to make profits. And doctors paying those premiums have a right to demand that the insurance companies do their jobs, and do them well, when they are sued. But doctors also have a right to pay reasonable premiums, not extortionate ones.

I tell my business law students that an insurance company is an animal with four legs. First is sales -- the people who go out and deal face-to-face with the insureds, finding customers. Second is underwriting -- the people who assess the risks that the customers represent and set the premiums at the rate necessary to make it worth the company's while to absorb that risk. Third is claims -- the people who deal with first- and third-party claims and pay out the reasonable value of losses resulting from the risks that the company has agreed to assume. Fourth is asset management -- between the time that premiums are collected and losses are paid, the money does not sit idly in a bank, gathering 1.2% interest. The money is invested in real estate, stocks, bonds, and business ventures.

When one of these legs weakens, the others have to become stronger to hold the animal up. Three of them are interrelated. Sales' success is driven largely by the willingness of underwriting to accept low premiums. Underwriting's success is dependent on claims' ability to keep the magnitude of risks down. Claims' success is related directly to the ability of underwriting to carve out unacceptable risks and deny coverage whenever possible, which in turn is affected by the promises made by sales. Asset management's performance depends, however, largely on how well the stock market and real estate market do. Lately, both have been doing quite well.

Now, it's true that the insurance industry has had a real bad run of it for the past fifteen years or so on the claims side. Big earthquakes in California, floods all over the midwest, hurricanes in the south, terrorists in the northeast, fires all over the west. And for a while, asset management couldn't help much when the market was in the tank. But that's not the case anymore. The animal can stand on its own quite nicely, thank you very much; asset management is no longer weak, so underwriting no longer needs to overcompensate for the run of bad luck claims has been experiencing. Sales would sure appreciate it if you lowered the premiums, guys; ever hear of "market share?"

Fifth, two out of every thousand claims filed results in a successful verdict. There is only one way to interpret this, and that is that Tennessee juries are reluctant indeed to find against a doctor under all but the most egregious of circumstances. Tennessee is a very conservative state with a lot of rural areas; most people know the defendant doctors socially at one level or another, and simply cannot be relied upon to be objective in weighing the evidence no matter how much they assure the court and the attorneys to the contrary. And that's the way it is.

So. Will the TMA's suggested reform -- similar to California's MICRA, a $250,000 limit on general damages and a structured attorney's fee schedule mandated by statute -- produce the results they claim to be going for, namely, lower premiums? Doctors in California are entering their tenth straight year of dramatic malpractice insurance premium hikes, and MICRA has been around there since the eighties. A look at the revenue and expenditures shows you why -- litigation defense costs account for 3-4% of premiums, and claims payments account for 33-34%. The rest goes to the insurance companies themselves.

Yes, doctors are paying too much for malpractice insurance. But it isn't the lawyers' fault; it isn't because doctors are being sued too much. Lawyers know the odds, and they are only going to push a case to trial if they think they have a realistic shot at a big verdict. Even then, they lose much more often than not. The odds clearly favor the doctors; the TMA admits as much. The reason premiums are high is because the insurance companies are funnelling the premiums to other areas of operation. Maybe they're making up for revenue shortfall resulting from higher than expected claims. Maybe they're trying to re-seed the investment pools. But whatever they're doing, they're keeping sixty cents on the premium dollar -- so maybe they're just greedy, which is an indisputable truth to a point; the question is whether the desire for profit (which is not necessarily bad) has gone beyond a point where broader social utility is being realized. Finding that balancing point where insureds, claimants, stockholders, and society as a whole all have their interests realized to an acceptable degree is why insurance companies are regulated in the first place.

When I sat down to start writing this piece ninety minutes ago, I hadn't intended to write so much. But there it is -- and I'm pretty confident in this. Doctors are free to rally against lawyers politically if they think it is to their advantage to do so. But it's not. They should be lobbying for meaningful insurance premium regulation, at least as significant corrolary to their desire for tort reform.

I guess the last piece in the puzzle to check out is -- where does the TMA get its funding? Is it all member-supported? Or do insurance companies themselves provide money to make the TMA's lobbying and political efforts work? That, I don't have the answer to and don't care to research at the moment, since it is rather late at night.