Tell me. I seem to have missed something.
Why can’t GM file Chapter 11? It’s out of dough. It’s out of liquid capital. It is being crushed under the weight of eleven different union contracts that have sucked all the profit out of the company. It’s sitting on top of what is still the world’s largest and most capable medium-manufacturing facilities, but it top executives can’t for the life of them figure out how to use those remarkable assets to sell a car that anyone wants to buy.
But it refuses to put a Chapter 11 on the table – in part because a bankruptcy judge would almost certainly appoint a trustee to administer and abrogate all of the contracts, both with the unions and its executives, sell out equity in the company to third-party investors and thus dilute shareholder value, and maybe even break the company up into multiple competitors, the way AT&T was broken up in the 1980’s.
But, from the perspective of the public benefit and the role GM plays in the economy, would any of that be so bad? The breakup of AT&T was good for competition, and the market is coalescing back into a world where there are only two or three major providers anyway.
Independent manufacturers think, well, independently from one another. GM itself consists of several "companies" like Saturn, GMC, Pontiac, Cadillac, and Chevrolet. Making these companies truly independent of one another seems, in principle, like a good thing.
There is no reason for GM to sell three functionally identical mid-sized sedans or four functionally identical SUVs, under different names and by different "companies" within GM. Sure, each of the companies has a slightly different flavor from one another. But they're all peddling basically the same cars.
Someone said once, what's good for General Motors is good for America. I say, competition in the open market is good for America. We've outgrown General Motors. It's time to break it up -- not by antitrust action, but by the company spinning off into separate components and really competing. Toyota would be the biggest automaker in the world, followed by Tata, but so what?
Really -- so what?
Not A Potted Plant Has A New Home
Readers! Not A Potted Plant is moving. Please switch your RSS feeders like Google Reader, and update your bookmarks, to draw from the blog's new site, generously hosted by the League of Ordinary Gentlemen. Thank you for your continued support.